Keegan Allen, Then
In the first episode Toby Cavanaugh appears in, he is played by James Neate, but was replaced by Keegan Allen for the rest of the series. Allen’s first acting role was in an episode of the Nickelodeon series “Big Time Rush,” shortly before he got his role on “PLL.” But, his passion usually leads him behind the camera, as he has had ambitions to be a photographer and cinematographer since he was young.