Jim Gaffigan’s Brief Appearance
In the season two episode “The Camel” when Pawnee City Hall looks for a new mural, Donna presents a version of “The Last Supper” featuring Hoosier celebrities including David Letterman, Larry Bird, John Mellencamp, and Greg Kinnear as Jesus. One celebrity who appears in Donna’s mockup but for some reason isn’t mentioned by name is comedian Jim Gaffigan, who would have made for a great guest star as one of Pawnee’s colorful characters.