Tara Reid (Then)
At first, Dani Sullivan appears to be the perfect match for J.D due to their similar personalities and relationship struggles. However, due to J.D’s unresolved feelings for Elliot, Dani realizes she will never truly win his affections and breaks up with him. Tara Reid had previously starred in “Days of Our Lives” and played Melody Valentine in “Josie and the Pussycats.”