30 Days of Night (2007)
This Josh-Hartnett-Vampires-in-Alaska film was oddly not well-reviewed. This comes as a surprise to me, because I remember when it came out everyone I knew loved it. It also was not one of the slew of horror remakes that critics were hating on at the time, and its cast and look seemed a cut above. Basically, this seems like the type of horror movie that wouldn’t be badly reviewed, since it’s not only a good movie, but also has a patina of respectability. Maybe it is just too violent. Heard that before?