An Obscure Law
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dfe1a/dfe1a2a8aff8474901b3f2bfde8513a04119dc52" alt=""
The Treasure Act of 1996 claims that any object found that is older than 300 years, is not a coin, and contains 10 percent precious metals needs to be reported to the local coroner within a 14 day period, which Kate failed to do.
Kate’s actions were now considered a criminal offense – and all because she wanted to keep her sentimental artifact. But who was right?