Her Imaginary Friends
When my child was about four or five, she claimed she had three imaginary friends: Eenie, Miney, and Moe. They apparently referred to her as Meenie.
But that wasn’t even the creepy part—the creepy part was the fact that she told me her imaginary friends don’t like to go into her closet because there was a creepy old man in there. I checked her closet several times, but never found anything. Story credit: Reddit / MatthewDLuffy