Stealing VS Taking
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7868b/7868b4705544bb6401e64046266d7d01e540df3e" alt=""
Anders loved his pennies, they were his prized collection. He explained, “I wanted the inner satisfaction that God and I acquired this collection.”
“If I was at someone’s house and I found a penny, I would pick it up and I would keep it, I will always tell the person that if it was a quarter, I would give it back, but since it is a penny, I’m keeping it”