Tickle Me Mary
I was at a friend’s birthday sleepover and we started to play “Bloody Mary.” It’s when each person takes a turn going into a dark room with a mirror and say “Bloody Mary” three times into it. The legend is that you will see a person in the mirror.
One of our friends went into the room (the birthday boy’s sister’s room) and was obviously scared. We hear him start to say it and then hear “Oh, that tickles!” He stepped on a Tickle Me Elmo and set it off. We heard laughing then crying. Story credit: Reddit / tyhad1